Eli Manning & Abby McGrew – Quogue, Estimated $8.5 Million
Eli Manning has been with the New York Giants since 2004 and he is already a two-time Super Bowl champion as of today. He was also the Super Bowl MVP during both of those wins. Thanks to the massive fortune Manning has in his bank account, he can definitely afford to stay in an estate worth $8.5 million. Manning purchased his new mansion in Quogue back in 2017. The place has five bedrooms and it is sitting on 1.3 acres of land. Currently, Manning takes credit for being the Giants member with the most touchdown passes, completed passes, and passing yards.